Tony204ing wrote:I have never heard of a buckshot only place. but i suppose im going to now.
Yep. You sure are. There are a lot of places in Virginia that are buckshot only, and even more hunt clubs that limit you to buckshot only. Close standers, small pieces of woods to hunt, flat terrain, heavy cutover/swamp, tradition..all combine to make for "buckshot only" rules.
I've never killed a deer with anything but buckshot. I've never even seen but two deer that were killed with anything else. One with a 30/30 rifle, and one with a slug. I've seen hundreds that were killed with buckshot.
Buckshot is as good as anything else when used within it's limitations, same as a rifle or a slug. Yes, it will cripple when people try to stretch the range, but so will rifles and slugs. Those two just happen to have a longer range to work with.
As stated above you have to know your gun. You wouldn't hunt with a rifle you hadn't sighted in, you shouldn't hunt with a shotgun you haven't checked out with buckshot either.
Personally I like Number 1 buck (12 ga), usually Remington, but the brand really isn't too important to me. Number 1 is the best compromise between number of shot (24/21 in a 3"/2 3/4" magnum shell) and size of the shot (.30) in my opinion. Longest shot I've ever made with 3" Number 1 was about 35-40 yards. Took a couple of shots, but the deer went down. I've never had a one shot kill, but I've never had to shoot but one more than twice. I've never lost one either. Every deer I ever shot at, went down and stayed down. (The closest one I ever shot was about ten yards.)
I've never killed a deer with 000, but the ones I've seen killed with it dropped like they'd been hit by lightening. 000 breaks bones like matchsticks. I think I've seen one deer killed with 00. The group I hunted with, no one seemed to like it for some reason. I don't think I've ever seen one killed with Number 4. I have known people to use it for the first shot, in case a turkey showed up, but from what I saw, that meant they didn't kill a deer or a turkey.