by Bowhunters » Wed Nov 26, 2008 4:31 am
Certainly doesn't sound like he's giving it the best of care but it really doesn't sound like the temperature is a problem if it indeed only got up to around 40 degrees F.
As Doc said, for aging it doesn't hurt a deer carcass to be in the 33-40 degree window and if it only got up to 40F and the carcass was in the shade of an unheated garage the carcass will never get close to that. If it was out in the sunlight or got warmer than 40F for a period then its an issue.
Leaving it lay on the garage floor is what bothers me in your story, the thought of a dog, cat, rat, mice, etc. possibly getting in there and munching on my deer makes the thought of deer steaks or chili a hard thing to swallow, literally. LOL
Laying on the floor also doesn't help age the meat very well, hanging it does best because the weight of the carcass actually helps stretch the meat as it hangs there and that stretching helps the meat be more tender and helps aid in cooling the carcass.
The closer to freezing the carcass is at as it hangs the longer it needs to hang to age so if its been pretty close or just below freezing at night and upper 30's to 40 for highs then 9 days probably isn't out of line, but again laying on the floor instead of hanging is the big issue I would have.