by KwackWacker » Tue Aug 02, 2005 2:37 pm
I think they are here for good. I've got a friend who is on the match grade gun business and he tells me they are here to stay. From what I understand, bench shooters really get the benefit of short magnums and super short magnums. Here's the way it was explained to me. I'm using a .270 as an example because that's the way i was told. The .270 has a fairly long shell casing. When the primer is fired it takes a while to burn all the powder through that long shell casing (keep in mind that a while in ballistics terms is measured in less than a thousandth of a second). The bullet is propelled from a fairly long burn of the powder and ,as I'm told, some of the powder burning towards the bullet end of the casing never has a chance to push the bullet because the bullet is already headed down the barrel. With the short magnums and super short magnums the casing is much shorter and the powder can burn all at once. Therefore you get one big push from the gasses rather than a long, slow burn. And all of the powder is used to propell the bullet. The difference comes in velocity and energy. One fast burn makes a bullet go faster and carry more energy than one longer burn. However, I don't think you would notice a heck of a lot of difference in the woods. The guys shooting from a bench don't seem to notice as much of a difference in velocity from shell to shell with the short magnums and super short magnums like they do with traditional loads. (once again, the differences can be very subtle, like 3 to 4 FPS, but this can make a big difference when you measure your groups by minute of angle rather than inches.) I don't think that the new rounds will put our traditional rounds out of business, but I believe they are here to stay.
Keep the tradition alive, teach a kid how to hunt.